You are hereBlogs / WcP.Movie.Critic's blog / Movie. Tagline of Goya's Ghosts - "Tell me what the truth is". Do you believe truth confessed under torture?

Movie. Tagline of Goya's Ghosts - "Tell me what the truth is". Do you believe truth confessed under torture?


By WcP.Movie.Critic - Posted on 17 December 2008

movie: Goya’s Ghosts

In the award-winning "Goya's Ghosts," set in late 18th-century Spain, a desperate father trying to rescue his innocent daughter attempts to prove that if subjected to torture, even the most innocent man of cloth will confess to the most preposterous absurdities.

After Inés Bilbatua (one of the artist Francesco Goya’s muses) is arrested by the Holy Office, then tortured and forced to make a false confession, her father, Tomas, also a friend of Goya’s, extracts revenge on Lorenzo, forcing him to make a confession of his own.

(quote)

From the movie:

...

Inquisitor: Were you served pork?
Inés Bilbatua: But I didn’t have any. I don’t like it. I don’t like the taste.
Inquisitor: Are you prepared to swear on the Holy Cross?
Inés Bilbatua: I swear on Jesus’ sacred wound, I’m telling you the truth.
Inés Bilbatua: And I would suppose you would not object if you are given an opportunity to prove it?
Inquisitor: No. I would be grateful. How would you like me to prove it?

(The girl was then brutally tortured - i.e., put to “The Question”.)

Inés Bilbatua’s parents in Goya’s Ghosts

...

(Inés’ family invites Brother Lorenzo and family friend Artist Francesco Goya to dine at their home to seek Lorenzo’s help with rescuing their daughter.)

Brother Lorenzo: I presume that you are anxious to have some news of your daughter.
Inés’ father, Tomas: Oh, yes. Extremely so. She has never, ever been away. Have you seen her?
Brother Lorenzo: (Regarding her release,) I couldn’t say. She must stand trial.
Inés’ father: Stand trial?
Brother Lorenzo: for what she has confessed.
Inés’ mother: What did she confess?
Brother Lorenzo: She confessed that she had secretly practiced Jewish Ritual of her forbears.
Inés’ mother: But that’s impossible. We are an old Christian family.
Brother Lorenzo: Correct me if I’m wrong. but the brothers in charge of the archives informed me that your grandmother’s great-grand father converted from Judaism to Christianity when he came to Spain From Amsterdam in 1624.
Inés’ father: but I’m the only person in the family who knows that.
Brother Lorenzo: Then why has your daughter confessed to it?
Inés’ father: Inés couldn’t confess to something she has no knowledge of.
Stellan Skarsgård - Francisco Goya
Inés’ brother: Was my sister put to “the Question” (torture)?
Brother Lorenzo: Yes, she was (tortured). She was in fine spirits.
Inés’ mother (shocked): My daughter was tortured.
Brother Lorenzo: She was put to “the Question”.
Inés’ father: I thought that kind of “Question” was abandoned years ago.
Brother Lorenzo: Yes, it was. It was. But now in these troubled times, in its quest for truth, the Church is bringing it back.
Inés’ brother: So, you maintain that a confession obtained by the means of, as you call it, “the Question”, is valid proof of anything?
Brother Lorenzo: This isn’t an opinion of one simple monk, sir. It is a tenet of Church teaching that confession obtained by “the Question” constitutes ultimate proof.
Artist Francesco Goya: I’m sorry. Father Lorenzo, but how can this sort of confession be ultimate proof? If I were tortured, I’d confess to anything. I’d confess I was the Turkish Sudan.
Brother Lorenzo: No, you wouldn’t.
Artist Francesco Goya: Yes, I would. I would confess anything to avoid pain.
Brother Lorenzo: No, you wouldn’t. You are God-fearing man, Goya, aren’t you?
Artist Francesco Goya: Of course, I am.
Brother Lorenzo: So, your fear of God would prevent you from making a false confession.
Artist Francisco Goya unveils a portrait
Artist Francesco Goya: But what if the pain obscured my senses. What if my fear of pain became bigger than my fear of God?
Brother Lorenzo: If you’re innocent of the charge, God would give you the strength to withstand the pain.
Inés’ father: Are you sure of that?
Brother Lorenzo: Yes.
Inés’ father: Forgive me, Father Lorenzo, but have you ever been put to “the Question” yourself?
Brother Lorenzo: Have I ever been?
Inés’ father: Have you ever been subjected to “the Question”?
Brother Lorenzo: Of course not.
Inés’ father: Do you think if you were and they ask you to confess something grotesquely absurd, say you were told to confess that you are really a monkey... Are you sure that God would grant you the fortitude to deny it, or would you rather confess to being a monkey to avoid the pain?
Artist Francesco Goya: (Laughs.) I know I would.
Inés’ father: I know you would. So would I.
(To Father Lorenzo -) Would you?
Artist Francesco Goya: Are you playing some sort of silly game with your guest? Nobody would ever ask Father Lorenzo to confess something so absurd.
Inés’ father: I would.
Javier Bardem as Brother Lorenzo in movie Goya’s Ghost
(To everyone’s puzzlement, he leaves the room.)
Artist Francesco Goya: Is he serious?
Inés’ mother: Oh, I’m sure he’s not. Alvaro, go get your father.
(To Goya and Lorenzo -) Sometimes I don’t understand his humor.
Artist Francesco Goya: Nobody does.
Brother Lorenzo: Nobody does.
Alvaro: Because my father doesn’t have a sense of humor.
Artist Francesco Goya: No, he doesn’t.
Inés’ father (who comes back into the room and reads from a piece of parchment in his hand):
“I, Lorenzo Casamares, hereby confess that contrary to my human appearance, I’m in fact the bastard son of a chimpanzee and an orangutan, and I have schemed to join the Church in order to do harm to the Holy Office.”
(To Brother Lorenzo -) Sign it.
Inés’ mother: This is a joke, Tomas, right?
Inés’ father: Angel, block the door.
Brother Lorenzo: Francisco, escort me out of this house.
Inés’ father: Stop Senor Goya.
Inés’ mother: You’re crazy.
Natalie Portman as Inés in the movie Goya’s Ghosts
Inés’ father: Did he let my daughter go?
(To Brother Lorenzo -) Did you let my innocent daughter go?!
(To others -) Keep him here.
Let Senor Goya go.
Inés’ father: Are you ready to sign the confession?
Bring him here.
(To Brother Lorenzo -) Sign it.
Tie his hands.
(To Brother Lorenzo -) Will you sign?
All right, let’s find out if God will give you strength to resist “The Question.”

...

Director: Milos Forman
Runtime: 113 min

Awards:
Best International Movie (Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA); Goya Awards; Satellite Awards

Inés thrown in prison; Brother Lorenzo visits

Cast:
Javier Bardem (Brother Lorenzo)
Natalie Portman (Inés/Alicia)
Stellan Skarsgard (Goya)
Randy Quaid (King Carlos IV)
Michael Lonsdale (Grand Inquisitor)
José Luis Gómez (Bilbatua)
Mabel Rivera (Maria Isabel Bilbatua)

(unquote)

Images courtesy of IMP Awards, stellanonline.com, and Samuel Goldwyn Films

Original Source: European Film Award Reviews and IMDB

Contact Us

Contact Us

RSS feed

Subscribe to WcP Blog RSS feed

Twitter

WcP Blog on Twitter

Facebook

WcP Blog on Facebook

Custom Search



Archive Calendar

September 2020
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930


Random image

Poem in Art: I love the stillness of the wood... - Lewis Carroll

Poll

Search the Web

Custom Search

Featured Videos

Latest Quote

"We come from the earth.
We return to the earth.
And in between we garden."
- Author Unknown

"If you have a garden and a library, you have everything you need."
- Cicero

Recent comments

Reader Reviews

  • "Great culture sharing. This is really important to show all over the world and different cultures and nature to whole world." - Anonymous (January 27, 2019)
  • "This is one of the most incredible blogs I've read in a very long time. The amount of information in here is stunning, like you practically wrote the book on the subject. Your blog is great for anyone who wants to understand this subject more. Great stuff; please keep it up!" - Anonymous (May 29, 2018)
  • "I am just happy to know about your website. It's informative and valuable for me. Thanks for sharing interesting info with us. Keep doing best in future." - Kelvin (May 28, 2018)
  • "Very good and creative website, graphics are wonderful." - Ricky (October 7, 2017)
  • "This is absolutely fantastic photography. I recommended to lovers of photography." - Christina (June 30, 2017)
  • "Your website seems to have precious gemstones on the subject of penning." - Bryce (March 29, 2017)
  • "Your articles are constantly awesome. You compose with exactness and your data is constantly precise. What's more, those two things make an article go from great to awesome! Continue distributing more extraordinary articles." - Ayesha (March 19, 2017)
  • "You are doing an amazing job." - Jake (January 4, 2017)
  • "I am an anthropology student and this site has helped me a lot to know more about the various cultures across the world. This is the reason I visit the site so often. Keep on sharing more and more posts like this. Thank you." - Anonymous (April 3, 2016)
  • "Your site is valuable. Appreciative for sharing! Awe inspiring Blog!" - Anonymous (March 16, 2016)
  • "This blog is the book which has feelings for around their lives. Will you produce intense addons." - Anonymous (January 26, 2016)
  • "Interesting quote. I have gone through different posts in this website. I could see different themed quotes and interesting posts here. I am much impressed with this website. Keep up the good work and keep sharing interesting stuff." - Howard (January 25, 2016)
  • "I was so impressed by it I felt I would reach out to you to say thank you. Great work...that's one great blog you've got there!" - Kayla (January 8, 2016)
  • "This is incredible. Finally something new. I was reading comics the whole time. This is the real fact, which I do not think anyone else has such a well written and updated blog like yours." - Zach (January 7, 2016)
  • "The Superbly defined stuff of reading, you constructed a masterpiece with your magical mind. Your writing skills are simply awesome. Great work!" - Katie (December 28, 2015)
  • "This really shows that you can still find folks that care about the things they post online. I really liked browsing the comments." - Myles (December 23, 2015)
  • "Yes i agree with the above poem that window is the world so far i have come across. Every thing comes from it. You have written in a very poetic way. Looking forward for more poems from this." - Anonymous (December 11, 2015)
  • "Every last tip of your post is incredible. You're really great to share. Keep blogging..." - Anonymous (December 8, 2015)
  • "I always take pleasure in your articles. You have a gift for discussing such stirring topics in ingenious yet amusing ways. Your posts help us realize that our troubles are typical, and we can solve them in ready to lend a hand ways..." - Angela (October 05, 2015)
  • "We all appreciate the power of words you always provide!" - Anonymous (October 05, 2015)
  • "So poetic..." - Anonymous (September 15, 2015)
  • "The method for composing is phenomenal furthermore the substance is first class. A debt of gratitude is in order for that knowledge you give the perusers!" - Anonymous (July 23, 2015)
  • "Your configuration, man...too astonishing! I cant hold up to peruse what you've got next.Thanks for your superb posting!" - Anonymous (July 16, 2015)
  • "I found myself starring at these photos. I cannot believe that I haven't seen them before, taking into account that I am mesmerized by sea and ocean as one can be by forces of nature. Thank you so much for putting them out here, because even though they were posted by such a giant as National Geographic, I still have missed them. Well, “dazed” is the exact word that describes the feeling that I felt when I first set my eyes in these photos." - Anonymous (July 14, 2015)
  • "I will check your different articles without further ado. Continuously so fascinating to visit your site. Thank you for sharing, this will help me such a great amount in my learning." - Anonymous (July 10, 2015)
  • "Extraordinary stuff, just basically astonishing! Keep it up in future. I am truly inspired by this site!" - Anonymous (July 3, 2015)
  • "I was reading your post since 2012 and you are writing so much outstanding ideas I must say you are a talented person." - William (June 29, 2015)
  • "I have never seen such amazing thoughts displayed in composing. Your author has an extremely one of a kind method for exhibiting data so as to catch the peruser's consideration." - Anonymous (June 27, 2015)
  • "Mind boggling posting! I really like the way you are sharing the exceptional tackle this subject." - Anonymous (June 25, 2015)
  • "I unquestionably appreciated all of it and I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post in the future." - Anonymous (June 13, 2015)
  • "I was very thrilled to find this website. This is really interesting and I have recommended this site for my friends also. I had a fantastic read from this blog." - Anonymous (June 2, 2015)
  • ""The exposition seeks to discover a haven inside character and communicate gratitude for life during its peaceful and thoughtful vibe." - Micheal (May 19, 2015)
  • "Fantastic Blog! I might want to thank for the efforts you have made in writing this post." - James (May 15, 2015)
  • "You are a good photographer your photography is good you click very nice shots which are very attractive and beautiful keep it up." - Ashlyn (May 5, 2015)
  • "Amazing! Great post! Wonderful pictures and well written article!" - Anonymous (March 10, 2015)
  • "Certainly worthwhile content! This is an excellent reference to spent time and gets authentic observation by reading." - Anonymous (February 12, 2015)
  • "Certainly exceptional blog! It is so wonderful content and acceptable with a clear concept. Thanks much!" - Lisa (January 13, 2015)
  • "Photography is my passion and like to learn something new about it. From your blog i have learned many things and i loved to read it thanks for sharing such a useful post" - Anonymous (January 1, 2015)
  • "Magnificent web blog! This is your superb consideration and appreciate your notion with this matter. Thanks a lot for sharing!" - Lisa (December 20, 2014)
  • "Undoubtedly enjoyed this blog! You set the subject content with exceptional abilities and a bit on the right track." - Lisa (December 17, 2014)
  • "It's an extraordinary joy perusing your post. It's loaded with data I am searching for and I want to post a remark that the substance of your post is wonderful. Thanks! :)" - Lilia (July 31, 2014)
  • "I do not even understand how I finished up right here, but I thought this to be great. I do not recognise who you are however certainly you
    are going to a famous blogger for those who are not already. Cheers!" - Gerald (July 24, 2014)
  • "Your blog is very informative. Also the images in it are beautiful!" - Anonymous (January 8, 2014)
  • "It is tempting to comment because of the amazing content on this blog. I wish I had a blog like this." - Anonymous (December 27, 2013)
  • "Thanks for trying to make the world a better place." - Anonymous (July 16, 2013)
  • "I have added to my favorites. I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. I believe this really is excellent information. Most of men and women will concur with you and I ought to thank you about it. Thanks for sharing." - Anonymous (May 16, 2013)
  • "This is awesome! Your photos are perfectly taken! It captured the decisive moment. I am a fan already." - Sarah (Apr. 15, 2013)
  • "Can I just say what a relief to obtain a person who truly knows what they're talking about on the web. You certainly know easy methods to bring an issue to light and make it critical. Extra individuals must read this and comprehend this side of the story. I can't believe you're not even more well-liked considering that you absolutely have the gift." - Anonymous (Jan. 23, 2013)
  • "I wish to show my thanks to the creator of this blog. Keep contributing a good concepts and strategies. Many people will surely improve their skills by reading blogs like this." - Anonymous (Dec. 25, 2012)
  • "I really like your style but mostly your initiative. The world needs more writers like yourself." - Steve (Jan. 18, 2012)
  • "It must be very rewarding to have a long term project like this and too see the progress being made! Thanks for sharing it." - Mika (Jan. 18, 2012)
  • "This was a very eye opening video. It's made an impact on me. We're so unaware of the things that we do every day can destroy our ecosystem. The statistics are mind blogging especially the fact that 90% of big fish are gone. We need to stop this somehow. I'm going to spread this page to my mutual friends. Thanks for this." - Joseph (Jan. 15, 2012)
  • "I enjoy this blog a lot." - Liz (California, USA; Oct. 17, 2011)
  • "Keep up the good work you're doing." - Casper (Melbourne, Australia)
  • "Thanks for sharing some great content through your blog. It has been a sincere pleasure to read." - Anonymous
  • "Always fresh and fascinating." - Anonymous
  • "Cool bio[mission statement]." - Darin (California, USA)
  • "You have some beautiful images. Love your site!" - Susan (Washington DC, USA)
  • "I love your Blog." - Kate (Ireland)
  • "A great site highlighting many important issues." - Bob (New Zealand; Feb. 20, 2010)
  • "Love the images on this blog..there are some interesting articles about health I noticed...we tend to run a 50/50 risk of a heart attack...I noticed when in the USA recently everyone seemed huge..they ate massive meals...I reckon that is one cause of heart failure...just my opinion..but yeah these articles can be worrying to some folk so just heed the advice...I know I will." - Mick (The Sunshine Coast, Australia; Aug 29, 2009)
  • "Excellent blog." - Bill (Vancouver Island, Canada)
  • "Fantastic blog and educational articles, much enjoy visiting...Thank you!" - Lotus1150 (Alberta, Canada; Aug 28, 2009)
  • "Great site and awesome photos." - David (Washington DC, USA)
  • "I loved your website. Even finding some news about Turkey made me surprised." - Anonymous (Turkey)
  • "Gorgeous site ... the kind of place you could lose yourself for hours (suppose that was intentional?). Also, cartoons, commentary on the events of the times, etc. Great stuff." - Daniel (Nevada, USA; Jan. 03, 2009)
  • "...may your blog, ideas and efforts help many more people." - Anonymous (New Mexico, USA)
  • "Very cool site..." - Anonymous
  • "Amazing site, worth the visit every time... enjoy." - Sam (Saudi Arabia)
  • "Easy to read and well-designed." - Colin (Arizona, USA; Apr. 22, 2009)
  • "Unique mix of news, photos and poetry." - Frasier (Virginia, USA)
  • "Worldculturepictorial.com/blog is an extremely interesting collection of news articles. It calls itself "A Window On the World". The site contains a wide variety of topics, all very informative and pertinent to life in today's world." - Cynthia (Massachusetts, USA; Aug. 07 2008)
  • "Wow. Cool." - Christopher (Melbourne, Australia; Dec. 10 2008)
  • "An interesting way to check out the wonders of our world." - Anthony (Ohio, USA)
  • "Nice site, especially the rss icon." - Daniel (California, USA; Sep 10, 2008)
  • "Good blog - Everything from news to photography. Very informative." - "explicitmemory" (Texas, USA)
  • "Very informative site by prose and picture..." - Jeff (Michigan, USA)

AdSense unconfigured block. Click to configure.